Anyone weighing CIVILIAN Hotel in New York usually wants three answers: what a night costs, how large the rooms are, and whether the Theater District address makes up for the trade-offs. This review lays out the published room, fee and guest-review details and flags where sources disagree. A Nonstop Dan’s blog review puts the cheapest room at around $200 a night, though that is one reviewer’s figure rather than a verified rate.

Last checked: 2026-11-06

Starting rate: From

Anyone weighing CIVILIAN Hotel in New York usually wants three answers: what a night costs, how large the rooms are, and whether the Theater District address makes up for the trade-offs. This review lays out the published room, fee and guest-review details and flags where sources disagree. A Nonstop Dan’s blog review puts the cheapest room at around $200 a night, though that is one reviewer’s figure rather than a verified rate.

25 per night (search listing) · Average nightly rate: $207 (search listing) · Transit access: 2-minute walk to a subway station · Smoke policy: Smoke-free property

At a glance: what published sources confirm

1 Rooms and location

• 194 guestrooms across 27 floors, on W 48th Street between 8th and 9th Avenues (Virgin Atlantic Holidays)

2 Room size

• Cosy queen rooms measure 130–170 sq ft, and some rooms have hooks instead of closets (MICHELIN Guide)

3 Breakfast

• Continental breakfast is listed daily from 7:00 to 10:00 AM for a fee of USD 20 for adults (Expedia)

4 Guest rating

• A 9.4/10 guest rating from 2,156 reviews (Hotels.com)

Key facts

Fact	Detail
Neighborhood	Theater District, Manhattan
Address	W 48th Street between 8th and 9th Avenues
Distance to transit hubs	About one mile from Penn Station and Hudson Yards
Guestrooms	194 across 27 floors (203 in a Canary case study)
Smoke policy	Smoke-free property
Rooftop venue	Starchild Rooftop on the 27th floor
Breakfast	Continental, 7:00–10:00 AM daily; USD 20 per adult
Guest rating	Hotels.com 9.4/10 (2,156 reviews); TripAdvisor 4.7/5 (987 reviews)
Designer	David Rockwell

Specifications

The room count differs by source. Virgin Atlantic Holidays lists 194 guestrooms, while a HospitalityNet case study on the property’s lobby kiosks gives 203 rooms. The dining venues are named in the hotel description on TripAdvisor.

Attribute	Detail
Dining and bars	Carversteak (modern steakhouse), Rosevale Cocktail Room (cocktail lounge with live jazz), Starchild Rooftop; a restaurant, a nightclub and two bars or lounges per the Kayak listing
WiFi	Free in public areas (Kayak); complimentary in rooms (Virgin Atlantic Holidays)
Gym	No own gym; partner TEMPL gym one block away on 49th Street (Nonstop Dan)
Drinking water	No complimentary water bottles; Hydration Stations on each floor (MICHELIN Guide)
Cribs and extra beds	Rooms cannot accommodate cribs or extra beds (MICHELIN Guide)
Cozy Room bedding	One queen bed, maximum two guests; two twin or two queen beds can be requested at extra cost (Virgin Atlantic Holidays)
Check-in time	Not established in the research notes

What this means: Treat 194 and 203 as an unresolved difference, since no primary source settled it, and confirm the current room count with the hotel if the number matters to your booking.

How much is a night at CIVILIAN Hotel?

Reported room rates

One review on Nonstop Dan’s blog describes the cheapest room as around $200 per night. The same reviewer paid $253 for one night in August, in a spacious king accessible room. Both figures come from one guest, so they show what one stay cost rather than the hotel’s standard rate on a given date.

Fees on top of the rate

Sources disagree on the daily fee. Nonstop Dan lists a waived guest experience fee valued at $43 per day as a travel-advisor perk, while a separate guest review cites a $49 per day facility fee that covers breakfast. The research does not establish which fee applies to a given booking channel.

The trade-off: The rate you see is only the starting point, because the daily fee and breakfast cost can change the total, and the research did not confirm a current starting rate.

What guest reviews say about CIVILIAN Hotel

Guest reviews aggregated on Kayak praise the location near Times Square, Broadway and the subway, along with staff friendliness. Ratings are high across platforms, with Hotels.com showing 9.4/10 from 2,156 reviews and TripAdvisor showing 4.7/5 from 987 reviews, though the two scales are not directly comparable.

Beware: The rooms are extremely small even by New York City standards.

Guest review aggregated on Kayak

Small rooms are the most repeated complaint. A TripAdvisor-linked reviewer, a Hotels.com reviewer and guest comments on Kayak all describe small rooms. The Hotels.com reviewer measured a room advertised as a spacious queen at 200 sq. ft. and called that the only downside.

Breakfast draws mixed feedback. Guest comments on Kayak describe it as mixed, a TripAdvisor-linked reviewer called it basic, and a Virgin Atlantic Holidays review criticized limited vegetarian and vegan options.

What to watch: Guests who need space or a varied breakfast will find these trade-offs in the reviews, and the overall ratings do not reveal them.

Can 18-year-olds check into CIVILIAN Hotel?

The research notes do not state a minimum guest age for CIVILIAN Hotel and do not give a check-in time. Virgin Atlantic Holidays lists its Cozy Room with one queen bed for a maximum of two guests, which is the clearest occupancy limit in the sources.

What to confirm before arrival

• The minimum age for a guest making a booking and for guests checking in
• Occupancy limits for the specific room type booked
• The check-in time, which the sources do not list

The catch: Age and occupancy questions are easy to settle by contacting the hotel, and the sources here leave them open, so the hotel itself is the place to confirm.

Do celebrities stay at CIVILIAN Hotel?

The research notes do not name any celebrity guest at CIVILIAN Hotel, so this review makes no claim about who has stayed there. The sourced reasons for its appeal are the Theater District address and the Broadway theme. The MICHELIN Guide calls the hotel “an intricately detailed love letter to the glamour of Broadway itself,” and Virgin Atlantic Holidays describes the design this way:

Theatre is woven into every detail here, from rooms inspired by backstage dressing rooms to light fixtures featuring drawings of all 41 Broadway theatres.

Virgin Atlantic Holidays

The bottom line: The Theater District placement and Broadway design are sourced, but celebrity visits are not, so treat any celebrity claim as unverified.

Pros and cons

Strengths

• Location near Times Square, Broadway and the subway, per guest reviews aggregated on Kayak
• Theatre-themed rooms and public spaces, per Virgin Atlantic Holidays and the MICHELIN Guide
• Free WiFi in public areas and complimentary WiFi in rooms
• High aggregate ratings: 9.4/10 on Hotels.com and 4.7/5 on TripAdvisor
• A rooftop bar on the 27th floor

Trade-offs

• Small rooms, described across three separate sources
• Some rooms have no closets, and rooms cannot accommodate cribs or extra beds
• A daily guest experience or facility fee of $43 or $49, depending on the source
• Breakfast described as mixed or basic, with limited vegetarian and vegan options in one review
• No gym on site

Best for

• Budget-conscious travelers: Nonstop Dan says CIVILIAN rates can be significantly lower than InterContinental New York Times Square and Kimpton Theta. This is one reviewer’s comparison and includes no rate figures.
• Theatre-goers: The Theater District address and Broadway-themed rooms are the most consistent sourced reasons to book here.
• Travelers prioritizing Times Square access: Guest reviews place the hotel close to Times Square, but the sources give no walking time.

Pricing band

The sources support a price range rather than a single figure. One reviewer reports the cheapest room at around $200 per night, and another reviewer paid $253 in August for a king accessible room, before fees and breakfast.

Location and getting there

CIVILIAN Hotel sits on W 48th Street between 8th and 9th Avenues in the Theater District of Manhattan. Virgin Atlantic Holidays places it about one mile from Penn Station and Hudson Yards. Hotels.com’s location summary places it close to Times Square, Broadway, Radio City Music Hall and public transit.

The research does not include walking times to the nearest subway station or to Times Square, so check distances on a map before choosing the hotel for a short walk.

Alternatives in the same search set

• Arlo NoMad and Arlo Midtown appear in related search data. No rate, room or review figures were gathered for either property.
• InterContinental New York Times Square and Kimpton Theta are the hotels Nonstop Dan uses as its price comparison. No figures for those properties were gathered.

The implication: A fair side-by-side comparison needs rate and room data for each property, and the current research does not include it.

Our pick

Related reading: Hotel Canberra: Compare Named Hotels on Rooms and Reviews � Accommodation in London: Compare Hotels, Chains and Prices

Frequently asked questions

Is CIVILIAN Hotel smoke-free?

Yes. The Kayak listing describes it as a smoke-free property.

How far is CIVILIAN Hotel from Penn Station?

Virgin Atlantic Holidays places the hotel about one mile from Penn Station and Hudson Yards.

Does CIVILIAN Hotel have free WiFi?

Yes. Kayak lists free WiFi in public areas, and Virgin Atlantic Holidays lists complimentary WiFi in rooms.

How much does breakfast cost?

Expedia lists continental breakfast daily from 7:00 to 10:00 AM for USD 20 per adult. The MICHELIN Guide also lists service from 7 to 10 a.m.

How many rooms does CIVILIAN Hotel have?

Virgin Atlantic Holidays lists 194 guestrooms across 27 floors. A HospitalityNet case study gives 203 rooms, so the two figures conflict.

Does CIVILIAN Hotel have a gym?

No. Nonstop Dan reports that the hotel has no gym of its own and partners with TEMPL gym one block away on 49th Street.

Have celebrities stayed at CIVILIAN Hotel?

The research notes name no celebrity guest at this property.

The bottom line: The research notes name no celebrity guest at this property.